The Dutton House is reportedly haunted by spirits who cause unexplained phenomena like slamming doors, mysterious footsteps, and disembodied voices, with visitors and staff reporting a chilling presence, particularly in the basement bar area. Sightings of a man in a white shirt with a scruffy face, heard crying, and a general sense of a lingering, unknown entity contribute to its reputation as a haunted location, possibly tied to the original family or its history as an inn. Visitors and staff have reported hearing footsteps, voices, and even a little girl crying. Experiences include doors slamming shut on their own and a palpable sense of cold. One account details seeing a man in a white shirt with a scruffy face in a specific part of the house. The exact identity of the spirits is unknown, though speculation points to a Dutton family member, a child, or a young woman, given the house's history as a family residence and an inn. A particular area where visitors often sense a strange presence is the basement bar, reportedly connected to the Underground Railroad.