The Huebner-Onion Homestead is known for various paranormal phenomena, including phantom footsteps, unexplained piano music, cold spots, and objects moving on their own. Witnesses have also reported seeing apparitions, particularly a man on the balcony, and hearing the sounds of horse hooves, reflecting its history as a stagecoach inn. Some accounts also suggest the ghost of the first owner, Joseph Huebner, may linger after a suspected accidental death involving kerosene he mistook for whiskey. Common reports include unexplained piano music, the distinct sound of plates shattering, and the persistent sound of horse hooves clopping across the yard. People have reported seeing strange apparitions, including a man on the balcony, and shadows moving within the house. Ghost mist has also been described in the hallways. Visitors have felt cold spots, a feeling of being led by an invisible force, and observed appliances turning on or off by themselves. Objects, like mirrors and pictures, have been seen falling from walls. Investigators have captured orbs and other activity on camera. Some witnesses have also heard phantom footsteps and creaking steps around the house.