Hotel Bethlehem is known for its friendly resident ghosts who sometimes play the grand piano in the Tap Room or appear to guests in mirrors and at the foot of beds. Guests have reported disembodied voices calling names, objects moving, and vacuums turning on by themselves. Room #932 is considered particularly active, with one couple reporting a man asking "Why are you in my room?" before vanishing. Guests have seen figures in mirrors and at the foot of beds, and disembodied voices have called out names. Vacuums have been known to turn on and move around the hotel on their own, even when unplugged. The hotel's grand piano in the Tap Room has been heard being played by unseen hands. Room #932 is a well-known location for paranormal activity, with one couple experiencing a man appearing at their bedside asking why they were in his room. The spirits are generally considered to be friendly and not malicious. May Yohay: The spirit of May Yohay, a former owner's granddaughter, is believed to haunt the hotel, with sightings of her singing and dancing, and sometimes heard playing the piano. Other unidentified spirits are believed to have a playful and mischievous nature.