The Fishing Creek Lodge is described as being haunted by the ghost of an unknown man, sometimes referred to as "Old Lupin," who can be heard singing hymns at night. Guests have reported unexplained noises and doors opening on their own, with sightings of ghosts on the second floor. The building is an older structure with a history that adds to the "character" of the location. A man's voice has been heard singing hymns at night, a sound attributed to "Old Lupin," a headless ghost looking for his head. Multiple guest reports describe seeing ghosts in various rooms within the lodge. Guests have heard unexplained noises and doors opening on their own. Ghostly activity is often noted on the second floor of the building.