The Pawnee Bill Museum Ranch is considered haunted, with visitors and staff reporting phenomena like seeing apparitions, experiencing unexplained noises, and feeling a general sense of unease. One specific legend tells of a ghost residing within a painting on the staircase wall of the historic mansion, adding to the ranch's reputation for paranormal activity. Reports include seeing spirits or shadowy figures within the ranch house and on the grounds. Visitors have described hearing eerie sounds and noises, though the source is unknown. Some guests report a feeling of being watched or an overall creepy atmosphere, which contributes to the haunted reputation. A prominent legend speaks of a specific ghost being hidden within a painting located on the staircase wall of the mansion. The ranch was once home to Gordon "Pawnee Bill" Lillie, a Wild West show entertainer, and its long history likely adds to the collection of legends and tales.