The Winery at Marjim Manor is known as one of New York's most haunted locations due to reports of friendly spirits, including a spirit dog and women having tea, who date back to the manor's original construction in 1834. The manor is featured on the Haunted History Trail of New York State and its paranormal activity, which includes doors flying open, footsteps, and voices, is often linked to an incident where a man named Huebel shot his son, Louis, on a Thursday at 3:00 PM. There is a recurring phenomenon associated with the manor's history of deaths. On a Thursday afternoon at 3:00 PM, the French doors are reported to fly open as if Lewis (Huebel's son) is bursting through from the other side, according to a YouTube video. Guests and staff report hearing voices and footsteps from a staircase that no longer exists. A dog that belonged to the Sisters of St. Joseph is said to be present, brushing against people's legs as they sit. Eyes have been seen looking back from mirrors within the manor. A small chair in the Nubian Room is sometimes seen moving on its own. The winery's hauntings have gained significant attention, appearing on paranormal shows like Most Terrifying Places in America and Ghost Hunters.