The Old Caledonian Bed & Breakfast is reportedly haunted by "The Bearded Gentleman," a figure whose first appearance to the owner was in the Ruggles-Evans-Dent House shortly after they moved in. Guests have also experienced phenomena like strange noises, unexplained bumps in the night, and the appearance of a "friendly elderly voice" and unseen children at the nearby Caledonia Wine Cottage, which has been the site of numerous paranormal reports since its 2006 renovation. The most prominent reported entity is a figure known as "The Bearded Gentleman". Guests and residents have reported unexplainable occurrences, including strange noises and bumps in the night.