The Point Iroquois Lighthouse is reportedly haunted by shadowy figures, the apparition of a girl eaten by a bear, and the spirits of shipwrecked individuals, as well as the ghost of former keeper Bill Robinson, who is sometimes heard with his cane in the upper levels. The location is also known for unexplained cold spots, adding to its haunted reputation. One story describes the spirit of a girl who was killed by a bear at the lighthouse's location. Some accounts mention apparitions of shipwrecked individuals, with the lighthouse serving as a beacon for both ships and spirits. Tales of Native American phantoms are also associated with the lighthouse. Other reports include shadowy apparitions believed to be victims of past battles or shipwrecks. Visitors and staff have reported experiencing sudden, unexplained cold spots within the lighthouse. The ghost of a former keeper, Bill Robinson, is said to be heard walking with the sound of his cane in the upstairs area.