Hebron Lutheran Cemetery is considered haunted due to reports of a perpetual burning smell from the crematorium, unexplained cold spots, disembodied voices, and claims of car batteries draining upon visit. Some visitors have also described the unsettling sensation of being watched or followed by an angry caretaker, with one even reporting hearing the sound of a donkey or mule. The crematorium at the cemetery is said to emit a burning smell, even when it's empty. Some visitors have reported that their car batteries inexplicably drain and will not start when they are at the cemetery, even if the battery is new. Chills are reportedly felt over many graves. Voices have been heard within the cemetery. One person reported seeing an angry-looking caretaker following them, and described this figure appearing in different spots. The sound of a donkey or mule has been heard by some visitors.