Old Abilene Town has been cited as a historically haunted location with many reports of paranormal activity tied to its turbulent past. Ghost Tours of Kansas listed it as the state's most haunted spot in 2012. The hauntings are attributed to the cowboys, gamblers, and outlaws who died in the town during its time as a chaotic cattle town in the Wild West. Some of the most frequent paranormal sightings are those of spectral cowboys. Stories suggest that some of these spirits are cowhands who were killed in gunfights or caught cheating at cards. Visitors and staff report hearing a variety of strange sounds, including phantom footsteps, disembodied voices, and other mysterious sounds coming from the historic buildings. The town is said to have a generally eerie and unsettling atmosphere, especially after dark. It has been described as having an eerie atmosphere with dimly lit streets that evoke a sense of ghostly encounters.