Lake Prairie Cemetery is the subject of several ghost stories and urban legends, with many of the paranormal claims centered on the older, southern half of the grounds. Haunted accounts include ghostly apparitions, strange mists, and floating orbs of light. Visitors have reported seeing apparitions of deceased townspeople roaming through the cemetery. These ghostly figures are often described as fleeting glimpses or shadowy shapes seen from a distance. Sightings of unexplained ghostly mists and luminous orbs of light are commonly reported. Some believe these are signs of lingering spirits or paranormal energy.