Finch Cemetery in Portland, Indiana, is described as haunted by rumors of shifting or disappearing gravestones, especially the one for a boy named Cinderella, where the number of stones on a return path supposedly changes from the count on the initial journey. The cemetery is located at the Jay County Conservation Club and dates back to the late 1800s. The primary alleged haunting is that the gravestones at Finch Cemetery can move or vanish. There is a specific story about the grave of a boy named Cinderella, where the count of gravestones allegedly changes between a trip to his grave and the return journey.