The old Mayfair Hotel in Sanford is described as haunted by a variety of spirits, including a shadowy figure, a woman in white, a mischievous little boy, and a little girl who roams the area, possibly connected to Hollerbach's German Restaurant. Visitors have also reported hearing phantom piano music from the vacant building and stories of gruesome deaths associated with the site. A shadowy black figure is said to appear within the hotel. A classic spectral figure, a woman in white, is also rumored to haunt the location. A little boy is believed to play pranks on the hotel's grounds. Another reported spirit is a little girl who somberly wanders the area near Hollerbach's German Restaurant. Locals have reported hearing piano music drifting from the abandoned hotel. Some tales describe gruesome deaths occurring at the site, contributing to its haunted reputation.