The Lumber Baron Inn's haunting reputation stems from several tragedies, most notably the 1970 double murder of a young woman who was raped and strangled, and her friend, who was shot by the killer upon discovering the scene. Visitors report encountering the spirits of the young women, along with other phenomena such as unexplained whispering, footsteps, faint female voices, and a general strange presence within the historic Queen Anne-style mansion. Guests have reported hearing whispering and distinct female voices within the inn. The sound of footsteps, sometimes described as belonging to a former soldier, have been heard upstairs. A general strange or unexplained presence is often noted by visitors. The spirits of the women murdered in 1970 are believed to be present, and their peaceful coexistence is honored by the current owners. The 1970 Murder: In 1970, a 17-year-old runaway was sexually assaulted and strangled in one of the rooms. Her friend, who stumbled upon the scene, was then shot. The murderer was never found.